Unit 8: Reformation / Wars of Religion
A Challenge to the Existence of Evil
From Spinoza, Benedict de. Spinoza's Short Treatise on God, Man and Human Welfare. trans. Lydia Gillingham Robinson (Chicago: Open Court Publishing, Co., 1909), 145-146.
 
In the middle of the seventeenth century, a Dutch Jew expelled from his synagogue, Benedict de Spinoza (1632-1677), began to formulate and publicize his own conception of the Divine. He imagined a Perfect and Infinite Being who existed in all things and from which all things emanated. In his view, God and Nature were one, uniting the spirit and matter. Consequently, Spinoza soon insisted, there was no room for evil and no logical place for the Devil. Natural law, which for Spinoza was divine, could not be overturned, and therefore witchcraft could not possibly occur. Spinoza challenged all men to clarify their theological beliefs and definitions and to realize that evil had to be contradictory to the nature of the Divine.
“Devils”

We shall now treat briefly as to whether devils exist or not, in this wise: If a devil is a thing that is opposed to God and has nothing of God, it corresponds exactly with the 'nothing' of which we have previously spoken.

If, as some do, we assume him to be a thinking being, that neither wills or nor accomplishes good, but puts himself in opposition to God, he is surely very wretched, and if prayers can avail they should be offered for his conversion.

But let us see whether such a miserable being could exist for a moment, and we will find out at once that it could not; for from the perfection of the thing arises all its endurance, and the more existence and divinity it has in itself the more permanent it is. Since a devil has not the slightest perfection, how should he be able to exist? To which we add that constancy or duration in the mode of the thinking thing arises only through the union that such a mode has with God which springs from love. Since exactly the opposite of this union has been stated of devils they cannot exist.

Since there is no necessity to assume the existence of devils why assume it? For it is not necessary for us (as for some others) to assume devils in order to find the cause of hate, envy, anger and similar passions, because we have found them satisfactorily without such fancies.